a player who's athletic & tall should always beat a shorter that's athletic. it's honestly not a great comparison either way. two different styles of play. odds are, they wouldn't even match up against each other, ever. to do your question justice, i would say half man should win. they both are similar in age, similar knowledge of how to play a fundamental game. half man has the height, so he should win... if he doesn't let shane shoot three's all day (which a player of his experience, i doubt would). maybe be more clear about what you want next time nex.

__________________
Stays in the trenches.